Wines, not mines, in Margaret River

The latest unthinkable area to be targeted by the coal mining frenzy is the world-renowned wine and food area of Margaret River in south-west Western Australia. 

A town, a river and a region, it is one of that state’s main tourist destinations, offering a Mediterranean climate and a combination of surf coast and scenic hinterland as settings for rich and varied cultural and gastronomic experiences.

The people who moved there and gradually created this special — and sustainable — economic Eden know what they have to offer. They also know what they have to lose if the coal industry gets a toehold here.

Bye-bye Leederville aquifer, bye-bye rural peace and quiet, bye-bye Margaret River as a holiday refuge for the city-stressed.

This is the mine site on Osmington Rd, near Rosa Brook, 15km from the actual town of Margaret River, and a much-visited and picturesque part of the Margaret River region, with wineries, dairies, berry and olive farms, equestrian centres and charming rural B&Bs, like the owner-built Rosa Brook Stone where I stayed.

LD Operations is currently applying to mine coal underground here; other exploration leases await. As you can see from the swampy centre, it’s clearly a wet area, despite, as locals say, a dry winter.

It is inconceivable that they will be able to mine without damaging the aquifer, although I am sure they will find experts to assure us that this would be ‘unlikely’.

The visible neighbouring farmhouses are modern, new-ish; they weren’t expecting this. Nor were these inhabitants of the adjoining lifestyle block.

Locals like TV chef Ian Parmenter (left) and Brent Watson have formed a strong NoCOAL!itionmargaretriver group to fight this entirely inappropriate mine.

Ian Parmenter and his wife Ann moved here 20 years ago, building a haven — home and garden and orchard and vineyard — over that time. Brent Watson and his family run the highly successful Horses and Horsemen equestrian resort and training centre just down the road.

They have the support of the local Council, winemakers and tourism associations and notables such as James Halliday. Local member Troy Buswell says he’s agin it, but Premier Colin Barnett has finally stated that he is not about to step in and deny LDO their ‘due process’

And we all know what that portends.

At Rosa Brook Hall with Peter Rigby and Brent Watson. Photo by Derek Pool, Augusta Margaret River Times

Because I was visiting Collie, only two hours away, Ian asked me to speak at a public meeting the day before I headed home. About 70 people turned up at the Rosa Brook Hall to hear about what I’ve seen in coal areas in other states and were audibly shocked at the Rivers of Shame DVD shown afterwards. As a reward, I was treated to a Parmenter feast of a dinner — vegetarian, in my honour!

I know these good people had very full lives and livelihoods before this mine threat exploded and I know how much time they are now spending on trying to save them — and the future and water resources of the whole region. This is a huge part of the unfairness I see all around the country. I hope they can last the distance — and win — as all reason and justice say they ought.

If Mr Barnett is not thinking of the southwest’s water and longterm land use, he might like to think about this, which I’d read before this whole mining madness became public. It’s was in The Weekend Australian Financial Review May 22-23, 2010, ‘How space and place dictate your happiness’ by Deirdre Macken. She reported that Glenn Albrecht, Professor of Sustainability at Murdoch University, had studied the Upper Hunter’s existentially distressed coal mining area populations, where ‘everything they valued was being taken away, … shovel by shovel’. 

He became interested in finding places that work best for people, ‘health-enhancing environments’, and he and urban planner Roberta Ryan of Urbis independently agreed that  ‘the place in Australia that best captures the qualities that please the psyche is the Margaret River.’   

Says Ryan, ‘It’s the most extraordinary place… and it just feels like the most fantastic place to be. It helps that it has an incredible level of investment by locals and so the locals feel as if it’s owned by them.’

Which is why they won’t be allowing Mr Barnett to allow the mining company, under his rubber stamp legislation, to take it away from them — and the rest of us.

6 thoughts on “Wines, not mines, in Margaret River”

  1. Yes Sam, they left even the closest ‘neighbours’ in the dark. It’s common practice, since the law doesn’t require them to advise, as any other proposed industry would have to. A notice in the paper will do.
    I assume you have joined Nocoalition then? ( I am just a channel. but have continued to receive Brent’s emails from this group so have kept abreast of the many threats hitting the area and wider. Standing together is the key– and not expecting ‘the process’ to save you. It’s designed to work best for mining, not for landowners or communities.
    I feel for you all there, and in all the other coal areas I visited. Laws must be changed to put mining back in its box of just another business– no special laws.
    All power to you in MR; I believe you have a better chance than most.

  2. Sharyn,

    I live smack in the middle of the largest tenement (3914) taken out by the mining company and have only just got information forwarded to me by friends. In the first instance I am disgusted that the information hasn’t been made more public than it has been.

    I have two blocks totalling 85 acres and live permanently there on my peaceful and beautiful lifestyle property. My neighbours are Vasse Felix vineyards, McWilliams wineries complex, spud growers, protea farm, dairy farmers and a few others like me who enjoy the way of life in the area.

    I have now joined the cause/fight to have this absolute nonsense stopped. If myself or my wife can help in any other way, then don’t hesitate to email me.

    Sam from Boallia

  3. Good on you James, for writing about it. I am still involved in the MR ongoing fight, especially to help rebut what some PRs and pollies over there are saying wines and mine can co-exist– as in the Hunter!!!

  4. It would be a shame to see this mine go ahead in Margaret River. Im researching the proposed coal mine for a feature story im doing at university. I also have family down south who are involved in the Wine industry and are all against the idea. I enjoy reading all your stories Sharyn, this one in particular. James.

Comments are closed.